Getting an offer is a big moment, but it isn’t the finish line. What happens in the days after you receive it can be worth thousands of dollars over the life of the job.
The Cost of Not Asking
According to a survey by HR Dive, 55% to 63% of workers never negotiate their salary — and those who don’t leave an average of $7,500 on the table. It’s rarely about confidence alone: 41% say they don’t know what’s actually negotiable, and 36% say they can’t justify the ask. Yet in this Procurement Tactics survey, roughly 85% of people who did negotiate salary or benefits came away with at least some of what they asked for — offers are almost never pulled over a polite, professional counter.
Timing Matters
The best moment to negotiate is after you have a written offer, before you accept it. At that point, the employer has already decided you’re the person they want — you’re negotiating from a position of strength, not auditioning for one. Come with a range rather than a single number, and stay direct and confident rather than apologetic.
Salary Isn’t the Whole Offer
If base salary has little room to move, the rest of the package often does. A 401(k) match — commonly 3–6% of salary — extra paid time off, health benefits, tuition assistance, and childcare reimbursement are all real, negotiable compensation, not just perks on a slide.
- Ask what’s flexible even if salary isn’t: start date, signing bonus, remote or hybrid schedule, or a professional development budget.
- Put a number on non-salary benefits before you compare two offers side by side — an extra week of PTO or a stronger 401(k) match can meaningfully close a salary gap.
A Simple Script to Borrow
“Thank you for the offer — I’m excited about this role. Based on my research and experience, I was expecting something closer to [X]. Is there flexibility on the base salary, or on the broader compensation package?”
The Takeaway
Negotiating isn’t a confrontation. It’s a conversation, and most candidates who have it come out ahead.
| Evaluating an offer, or looking for your next one? Connect with an SSI People recruiter → |